Resources

Constructive Dismissal in Malaysia: What It Is and How to Prove It

Have you ever felt so miserable, undermined, or mistreated at work that you felt you had no choice but to resign? This feeling of being “forced out” isn’t just a personal struggle; it’s a recognized legal concept in Malaysia known as constructive dismissal.

Unlike a direct termination, constructive dismissal is when an employee resigns, but the law treats that resignation as a firing due to the employer’s unacceptable conduct. It is a powerful legal remedy for employees in intolerable situations. This guide will explain the legal test for constructive dismissal, provide common examples, and offer a step-by-step guide on how to prove a claim in Malaysia.

What is Constructive Dismissal? A Legal Definition

Constructive dismissal is a complex area of employment law. It hinges on the idea that every employment contract, whether written or verbal, contains an implied term of mutual trust and confidence. When an employer shatters that trust, the employee may be entitled to walk away and claim they were, in effect, dismissed.

Going Beyond Direct Firing: When Resignation Becomes Dismissal

In a constructive dismissal case, the employee is the one who technically ends the employment contract by resigning. However, they argue that they did not do so voluntarily. Instead, they claim the employer’s actions were a repudiatory breach of contract, leaving them with no reasonable alternative but to leave. If the Industrial Court agrees, the resignation is re-categorized as an unfair dismissal.

The Four-Part Legal Test for Constructive Dismissal in Malaysia

The Malaysian courts have established a clear, four-part test to determine if constructive dismissal has occurred. The employee must prove all four of the following:

1. Breach of Contract: The employer breached a fundamental term of the employment contract.
2. Fundamental Breach: The breach was so serious that it showed the employer no longer intended to be bound by the essential terms of the contract.
3. Employee’s Choice: The employee chose to treat the breach as a dismissal and resigned in response to it.
4. Timeliness: The employee resigned promptly after the breach occurred.

What Constitutes a “Fundamental Breach of Contract” by an Employer?

A fundamental breach is not a minor irritation or a one-off bad day. It is a significant violation that strikes at the very core of the employment relationship. This can be a breach of an explicit term written in your contract (like your salary) or a breach of an implied term (like the duty to provide a safe and respectful work environment).

Common Examples of Employer Conduct That Can Lead to a Claim

While every case is unique, certain employer actions are frequently cited in successful constructive dismissal claims.

Unilateral Changes to Core Terms: Salary, Demotion, and Location

An employer cannot unilaterally make significant, detrimental changes to the core terms of your employment without your consent. Examples include:

• Cutting your salary or removing contractual benefits.
• Demoting you to a substantially lower-status role without justification.
• Forcing you to relocate to a different city or state without a contractual mobility clause.

Workplace Harassment, Bullying, and Victimization

An employer has an implied duty to provide a safe and harassment-free workplace. If you are subjected to persistent bullying, sexual harassment, or victimization, and the company fails to take reasonable steps to protect you after you’ve reported it, this can constitute a fundamental breach. For more on this, it’s important to understand your rights as an employee.

Creating an Intolerable or Unsafe Work Environment

This can include a wide range of actions, such as deliberately isolating an employee, overloading them with an impossible amount of work to force them out, or failing to address serious health and safety concerns. The key is that the employer’s conduct, taken as a whole, makes it unreasonable to expect the employee to continue working.

The “Last Straw” Doctrine: A Series of Smaller Incidents

Sometimes, there isn’t one single major breach, but a series of smaller, negative incidents over time. While each incident on its own might not be a fundamental breach, their cumulative effect can be. The final incident, even if minor, can become the “last straw” that entitles the employee to resign and claim constructive dismissal.

Proving Your Case: A Step-by-Step Guide for Employees

Claiming constructive dismissal is a serious step with a high burden of proof on the employee. You must act methodically and strategically.

Step 1: Identify the Fundamental Breach

Be clear about what specific action (or series of actions) by your employer constitutes the breach. Is it a sudden demotion? A failure to act on a harassment complaint? Write it down and be specific about dates and details.

Step 2: Collect and Document Everything (Evidence is Key)

Your claim will succeed or fail based on your evidence.

• Save Emails and Letters: Keep copies of all relevant correspondence, including your employment contract, warning letters, and any written communication related to the breach.
• Keep a Timeline: Maintain a detailed log of incidents, including dates, times, locations, what was said, and who was present.
• Formal Complaints: If you haven’t already, put your grievances in writing to HR or your manager. This shows you tried to resolve the issue internally first.

Step 3: Resign Promptly and State Your Reasons Clearly

Once the breach occurs, you cannot wait too long to resign, as this may be seen as you accepting or “affirming” the new situation. Your resignation letter is a critical piece of evidence. You should explicitly state that you are resigning in response to the company’s specific breach of contract and that you consider yourself constructively dismissed.

Step 4: File a Representation Within 60 Days

After your last day of employment, you have a strict 60-day deadline to file a representation for unfair dismissal (under Section 20 of the Industrial Relations Act 1967) at your nearest Industrial Relations Department office.

The Legal Process and Potential Outcomes

Filing a claim initiates a formal legal process that can be lengthy and challenging.

What Happens After You File a Claim?

First, the Industrial Relations Department will schedule a conciliation meeting between you and your former employer to try and reach a settlement. If no settlement is reached, the case may be referred to the Industrial Court for a full hearing.

The Risks Involved: What If You Lose the Case?

This is the biggest risk. If the court finds that you failed to prove all four elements of the legal test, your claim will be dismissed. This means your resignation will be treated as a normal, voluntary resignation, and you will not be entitled to any compensation.

Potential Remedies Awarded by the Industrial Court

If your claim is successful, the court can award remedies similar to a standard unfair dismissal case. These typically include:

• Backwages: Compensation for lost earnings from the date of dismissal up to the date of the award (capped at 24 months).
• Compensation in Lieu of Reinstatement: An additional sum of money, usually calculated as one month’s salary for each year of service.

For HR Managers: How to Prevent Constructive Dismissal Claims

The best way to handle constructive dismissal claims is to prevent them from ever happening. This requires building a foundation of trust and procedural fairness.

Fostering a Culture of Respect and Open Communication

Proactively address issues of workplace culture. Promote an environment where employees feel safe to speak up without fear of retaliation. Addressing problems early is far less costly than litigating them later.

Establishing Clear Grievance and Anti-Harassment Policies

Have robust, well-communicated policies for handling employee grievances and harassment complaints. Most importantly, ensure these policies are followed consistently and that all complaints are investigated thoroughly and impartially.

Conclusion: A Powerful Right That Must Be Exercised Carefully

Constructive dismissal is a vital protection for employees in Malaysia, ensuring they are not forced to endure intolerable working conditions. However, it is not a decision to be taken lightly. The burden of proof is high, and the legal process is demanding.

For employees, it requires careful documentation and prompt action. For employers, it serves as a critical reminder of their duty to maintain a relationship of trust and confidence. By understanding the legal principles, both sides can navigate the complexities of the modern workplace more fairly and effectively.